The ideal TubeBuddy alternative should have the power of A/B Testing for thumbnails and more.
It should also be cheaper than TubeBuddy.
- This guide helps you find our next tool to replace TubeBuddy.
- We’ve got lists of of Features, Pros, Cons, Pricing, and Reviews…
- For every app on the list.
But first…
Why look for a TubeBuddy alternative?
This is the most common question: If TubeBuddy is already great, why look for a replacement in first place?
YouTubers benefit of these key features in TubeBuddy:
- A/B Testing: Test different thumbnails to see what works best for your audience, helping you optimize your content.
- Video SEO: TubeBuddy provides suggestions for optimizing your video titles, descriptions, and tags to improve visibility and ranking on YouTube.
- Thumbnail Generator: You can create viral thumbnails through screenshots and branding/text layers directly within TubeBuddy.
In may ways, TubeBuddy is already great for most users — though, it’s missing key features.
Title A/B Testing
This isn’t something you can do with TubeBuddy.
The app does thumbnail testing, but no sign of title testing. Others, like Thumbnail Test, provide title testing.
Pricing
- Pro Plan = $2.50 per month when you pay for a whole year at once. But honestly, it doesn’t offer much that you couldn’t do on your own without spending the money.
- Legend Plan = $15.75/mo (billed yearly), so only here you can start A/B testing.
Justified?
TubeBuddy is more of a hub for all of these features.
If you’re looking for something specific (e.g. just A/B testing or just YouTube SEO), you’d be better off with a tool dedicated to each niche.
Top TubeBuddy Alternatives
As of 2024, the best alternatives to TubeBuddy are Thumbnail Test and vidIQ. First one is for A/B Testing, and second is for YouTube SEO & Analytics.
Let’s explore them.
1. Thumbnail Test
Thumbnail Test offers a platform where YouTube creators can A/B test their video thumbnails and titles to optimize views and engagement.
Key Features:
- Test Thumbnails and Titles: Creators can test various thumbnails and titles, even combining tests for both, to see which combinations perform best.
- Multiple Test Options: Unlike standard A/B tests, Thumbnail Test allows for A/B/C/D/E testing, giving a broader range of comparison.
- Automatic Analytics: The platform automatically gathers data from YouTube Studio, making it easier for creators to assess performance.
- Flexible Testing Schedules: Offers both daily and hourly testing options to get results faster.
- Upcoming Features: Plans to include full thumbnail swap automation to optimize thumbnail performance further.
Pros:
- Ease of Use: The platform is designed to be user-friendly, allowing for straightforward setup and execution of tests.
- Comprehensive Testing: The ability to run multiple tests simultaneously offers a detailed understanding of what works best for a video’s visibility.
- Positive User Feedback: Users have reported significant increases in views after using the tool to optimize thumbnails and titles.
Cons:
- Limited to YouTube: Currently, the service is focused solely on YouTube content, which may not be suitable for creators looking for cross-platform testing.
Pricing:
- Basic Plan: $29/month, or $24/month when billed yearly.
- Pro Plan: $49/month, or $37/month when billed yearly.
- Business Plan: $99/month, or $75/month when billed yearly.
- Discounts: 40% off for Channels with fewer than 10,000 subscribers.
We care for everybody. Yes, including small YouTubers!
Reviews:
- 4.9/5 on ProductHunt
2. vidIQ
vidIQ is a tool designed to help content creators optimize their YouTube channels for greater reach and engagement.
Pros:
- Daily Ideas and SEO Tools: vidIQ uses AI to provide personalized thumbnails, video content suggestions and keyword research tools to optimize your content for better searchability and engagement.
- Competitors Analysis: Gain insights into your competition’s strategies, helping you understand what works and adjust your content strategy accordingly.
- Channel Audit: This tool analyzes your channel’s performance, highlighting strengths and areas for improvement.
Cons:
- Some users might find vidIQ’s full range of features to be expensive, particularly when starting out or operating on a tight budget.
- There’s a learning curve due to the abundance of features, which might be overwhelming for new users.
- No A/B testing features.
Pricing:
- Free plan
- Paid plans: $5 to $199 per month
Reviews:
- 4.7 on Trustpilot
Why Just 2 Alternatives?
We get it — they don’t look like much, and it may even look like this is staged, but it isn’t.
There are only two options in this list because:
- Thumbnail test is the only other reliable A/B Tester.
- vidIQ is the only capable SEO & Analytics competitor.
- And there isn’t any other app in-between.
As new tools come out, we’ll be sure to update the guide and give you the 100% most genuine options.
Leaving TubeBuddy For Good 👋
As time goes on, new technologies and ideas come into play.
What was effective before might not cut it today, and it might be the right moment to explore a new option to TubeBuddy.
Get going with ThumbnailTest to boost all of your videos.
Thank you for reading this,
ThumbnailTest
